Science ClubInstitution's Innovation Council, Ministry of HRD Initiative
SNR Sons Trust, Sri Ramakrishna Institute of Technology, HIVE and ASME SRIT
STEM Fusion Challenge

Evaluation rubrics

Download the full Rule Book (PDF)

Each online phase is scored out of 20 against the rubric below. The AI-assisted evaluation is subject to admin review, and you can request one re-evaluation.

Phase 1: Mathematics (20 marks)

Download Phase 1 report template (Word)

CriterionMarksFull marks look like
Mathematical modelling5Clear equations or relations describing the model, with variables defined.
Calculations and accuracy5Correct working shown step by step, with units.
Data, graphs and analysis4Labelled tables and graphs, trends interpreted, errors or uncertainty noted.
Optimization or logical reasoning4Options or values compared and the best choice justified with maths.
Clarity and presentation2Logical structure, readable PDF, correct notation.

Phase 2: Chemistry (20 marks)

Download Phase 2 report template (Word)

CriterionMarksFull marks look like
Chemical concepts identified5Correct principle (reaction type, rate, pH, redox, material properties) named and explained.
Equations and stoichiometry4Balanced equations; quantities and concentrations calculated correctly.
Experimental method and data4Procedure, controlled variables, observations or measurements recorded.
Analysis and justification4Results explained using chemistry; sources of error and improvements discussed.
Safety and environment3Hazards identified, safe handling and disposal, eco-friendly choices.

Phase 3: Physics (20 marks)

Download Phase 3 report template (Word)

CriterionMarksFull marks look like
Physical principles applied5Correct laws (forces, energy, heat, fluids, electricity, optics) linked to how the model works.
Calculations and units5Correct formulas, substitution, final answers with units.
Design and engineering reasoning4Design choices justified; alternatives considered and trade-offs explained.
Measurement and validation4Predicted values compared with measured values, with percentage error.
Clarity and diagrams2Labelled diagrams and a clear explanation of how it works.

Final jury evaluation (40 marks)

CriterionMarksLooks like
Working prototype10Does it do what the report says?
Integration of Maths, Physics and Chemistry8All three subjects genuinely used.
Innovation and creativity6Original ideas and approach.
Build quality and use of materials6Craftsmanship and sensible materials.
Oral explanation and answering questions6Clear explanation; confident answers.
Teamwork and individual contribution4Every member can explain their part.

Custom topic validation (pass/fail)

A team-proposed topic is approved only if all four conditions are met.

Three-subject linkUses a specific concept from each of Maths, Physics and Chemistry.
BuildableA physical model can be made with low-cost materials within the timeline.
MeasurableAt least one quantity can be measured and compared.
Safe and originalNo hazardous chemicals, open flame or high voltage; not a duplicate of a listed topic.

Ties are broken by jury marks, then Physics, then Chemistry, then Maths.